Up@dawn 2.0

Tuesday, February 13, 2018

Is it possible to prevent indoctrination of youth?

Essay for Feb 13

Most of us were subjected to political, religious, and social indoctrination before we became teenagers. While we have been learning of a few individuals who have de-converted from a particular religious belief, most people believe as their parents do or have been instructed by them to believe. That is easily understood when you think of the early interactions that you had with your immediate family or relatives.

If your family supported Republican candidates, then you generally only heard good things about Republicans. Any negative news about Republican behavior would be filtered by your parents to exclude it from you. The same is true of Democrats and today more than in the past, hypocrisy is revealed by replaying passed video clips as they twist themselves into pretzels trying to justify their current stance on an issue compared to their stance five years ago on the same issue. For example, both Senate Majority Leader McConnell and Speaker Ryan were predicting apocalyptic consequences as a result of expenditures that added to the deficit five years ago and this week when it was convenient for them, they added to the deficit saying that a growing economy would resolve it. The Democrats made the same counter argument five years ago.

If you are born in the United States, most of you had parents who belong to either the Catholic church or one of 200 major Protestant denominations, so you would have heard or read stories from the Old and New Testaments and nothing about other religions or their writings. You would have been taught  the “Founding Fathers,” supposed beliefs while ignoring what individuals like, Franklin and Jefferson said about religions. These untruths about them would be handed down from generation to generation. Today, if you attend a public university and you do a little research you discover that what you’ve been told is sadly not true or only half-true at best; however, if you show the proof to someone who has bought into the myth or misrepresentation, your proof, even if acknowledged, will generally be dismissed quickly.

If you were born in China, you might know very little about Judaism or Christianity, so how much of what you believe is determined by your place of birth? So many different cultures have belief and non-belief systems that are so different from those in the west. Some people in the U.S. were already disconnected from other cultures because they viewed them as inferior. Now as it is starting to dawn on a few of them that they are not inferior, there seems to be an effort to retrench and erect barriers to prevent reasonable cultural exchanges. We may soon find ourselves walled in to our detriment.


 Will there be a time in the far distant future when children are not indoctrinated, but instead taught to think critically about political, religious, and social issues? I have my doubts.

Quiz For Fantasyland Report

Here are some questions from our presentation.

1.What is the premise of this book?
2.What is one of the two events that helped "crystalize" the ideas in this book?
3.When did Andersen initially believe this phenomenon began?
4.What is one statistic you found interesting?
5. What was one of the modern tipping points?
6. What was one of the "revolutionary ideas" from Martin Luther's thesis that Andersen mentions?

These questions are only from the first two chapters so Ashley may add some additional questions later for more base points. :)

Saturday, February 10, 2018

Introduction to Fantasyland by: Kurt Anderson (Kathryn and Ashley's Report)

Hello Everyone!

Ashley and I will be introducing Kurt Anderson's Fantasyland on Tuesday. If you would like to read along, we will be going over chapters 1-4. However, if you do not have access to the book, our questions will come from our PowerPoint presentation. I do recommend the book to any interested parties. It is very interesting so far. We will make another post before class with the questions.


Here's the Google preview...

Hope everyone has a great weekend!

Alt questions from A&A Brewster (11-15).


1.       What was the significant discovery that David made about the first eleven chapters of Genesis? (114).
2.       What were Ethan Sahker’s six issues that must be met for a long-term relationship to work? (122).
3.       What common distaste did Ethan share with May? (125).
4.       What documentary did Kristen “Sen” Rurouni watch that crushed her and made her husband angry? (127-8).
5.       According to Matt Hart, “no amount of praying for health allows a family to escape what? (133).
6.       In the United States, what influences the values and beliefs that children will adopt and carry with them into adulthood. (137).
7.       According to Ronnelle Adams, who remains the “highest-valued targets of religious indoctrination.” (147).

 Alternative discussion questions.

1.       How has social media helped or harmed relationship forming between non-religious and religious individuals?

2.       Consider what Kira’s parents most feared and how does that relate to the experiences described by James Mouritsen and Cora Judd?


3.       Discuss some of techniques used to indoctrinate or brainwash children into following a certain faith and what can be done to intervene?

Skye & Don's Mid-Term Rpt Quiz questions

Questions:

1.    Name one type of logical fallacy mentioned.

2.    What Hindu God has the power of invisibility and could be hiding in your backyard?

3.    What is the difference between science and religion?

4.    Name one religion that shares a similarity to Christianity.

5.    What school did Guy Harrison graduate from?

6.    Name one scientist that Don mentioned who believed in the existence of God.

7.    Name one scientist that Don mentioned who did not believe in the existence of God.

8.    Don asked you to imagine a universe that had no what?

9.    Don’s experience can best be described by which of the three reasons he and Skye focused on?

 

Skye’s summary of arguments used during the debate:

Reasons Why God Exists:

1.         Someone I Trust Told Me He Exists:

a.         Scientist

b.         Scholars

2.         Nobody Has Ever Disproved the Existence of My God

a.         Science cannot prove everything

b.         That feeling of “little more” inside of us

3.         Science Can’t Explain Everything

a.         That comforting feeling in a hospital

b.         The desire to help other people

 

Reasons God Does Not Exist/ Responses to Don:

I.          Logical Fallacies

a.         Whose job is it to prove a claim?

b.         Does Absence of Evidence trump logic?

II.         Science and Religion are Inherently Different

a.         Science is based in fact

b.         Religion based in faith

III.        How Do You Know Your God is the one?

a.         4,200 religions

b.         Many before Christianity


c.         Many share beliefs with Christianity.

So much deeper than football

My son shared this with me.

Even before the Philadelphia Eagles won the NFC East, the NFC Championship, and finally the Super Bowl, there was a story that you may not have heard about. The Eagles's starting quarterback, Carson Wentz, who would later be injured and not be able to play the last few games of the regular season, the playoffs, and the Super Bowl, shared a simple thought worth remembering even when we watch a football game or any game. Some things are "so much deeper than football, so much more than a game."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dxvc4JFQrNA

Friday, February 9, 2018

Quizzes Feb 13, 15

AA 11-15

1. How did Billy Graham scare David?

2. What feelings did David often have in response to conversations with classmates at his small Christian college?

3.What was David's reaction to listening to Julia Sweeney?

4. What struck David as ridiculous, barbaric, and petty?

5. What do some studies show about marital satisfaction among the religious?

6. What was more important to Ethan than finding an atheist partner?

7. What calculation led Ethan to consider his chances of finding love bleak?

8. Does Ethan say he was raised atheist?

9. What did Sen question about her brother's fate?

10. What was Ronnelle's mother reaction to his coming out?

Post yours...


DQ

  • Have you ever been to an evangelical crusade? Was it scary?
  • Have you had supportive conversations on matters of (un)belief with peers? How'd they make you feel?
  • Have you seen/heard Letting Go of God? What was your favorite or most relatable part?
  • Do you consider the universe "miraculous" (116) and natural? 
  • Can you generalize about couples you know and their religion or irreligion?
  • What's the difference between your beliefs and your "worldview"?
  • Was Ethan too rigid? 122
  • Is atheism an effective form of "armor" against excessive piety? 125
  • Are you surprised that some Russians consider atheism "physically impossible"?129
  • Is it easier fort theists to remember to be grateful? 133
  • Why do you think "very smart people believe such obvious untruths"? 134
  • Is there a meaningful distinction between "magic" and divine "power"?
  • Yours please
Quiz Feb 15, AA 16-20

1. By what early teachings did Kevin consider himself "infected"?

2. Who coined the term "atheophobia"?

3. How do most theists deal with distasteful bible verses?

4. What does Kevin consider his parental responsibility with regard to religion?

5. Which of Dan Barker's principles does Kevin prefer to the ten commandments?

6. What ultimately made Amy an atheist?

7. What saddens Adrienne about her sisters?

8. To what stage of a relationship is agnosticism analogous?

9. What language did Justus find "stilted"?

10. What podcast helped Justus become more comfortable with his loss of faith?

DQ
  • What do you recall of your earliest religious instruction, and your earliest curiosity?
  • Have you encountered atheophobia personally?
  • Is it intellectually acceptable to cherry-pick bible verses, ignoring some and extolling others?
  • Are the ten commandments admirable?
  • If you're not now a parent, do you expect parenting to make you more conservative? 158
  • How would you react to your family "praying in tongues for your godless marriage"?
  • Does it bother you to have loved ones who are sure you're to hell? 166
  • Is it honorable to be an atheist? 167
  • How do you respond to people who consider evolution a dirty word? 168
  • Have you attended a Unitarian or Sunday Assembly service?
  • Does it feel like the Twilight Zone to you when you speak to theists who don't believe you're on the highway to hell?